Pitfalls and Risks

Medigap Lock-In: Why You May Not Be Able to Switch Back

Last verified

In plain language

This is one of the most important and least understood Medicare risks. At 65 you can buy any Medigap policy regardless of your health. If you instead choose Medicare Advantage and stay past the first year, then later develop health problems and want Original Medicare + Medigap, in most states insurers can turn you down or charge more. The choice you make at 65 can be hard to undo.

The rules that create lock-in

  1. One-time window: your 6-month Medigap Open Enrollment Period starts when you have Part B and are 65. It's one-time and can't be repeated.⁠[1]
  2. After the window: there's no guarantee an insurer will sell you a policy if you don't meet its medical underwriting requirements, unless you have a guaranteed-issue right.⁠[2]
  3. Federal law allows underwriting: Medigap insurers may use medical underwriting to deny a policy or charge higher premiums outside guaranteed-issue periods.⁠[3]
  4. The trial right is short: if you join Medicare Advantage for the first time, you have 12 months to return to Original Medicare and buy Medigap under federal trial rights.⁠[4]
  5. Dropping Medigap is risky: if you drop your Medigap policy to join Medicare Advantage, you may not be able to get the same policy, or in some cases any Medigap policy, back unless you leave during your trial period.⁠[5]

How it plays out

  • Illustration (based on the rules above): at 65 someone picks a $0-premium Medicare Advantage plan. At 70, after a cancer diagnosis, they want to see an out-of-network specialist and switch to Original Medicare + Medigap during Open Enrollment. They can leave Medicare Advantage,⁠[6] but a Medigap insurer may deny them or charge a higher premium because of the diagnosis.⁠[2]⁠[3] They could be left with Original Medicare's 20% coinsurance and no annual cap.⁠[7]

State variation

  • KFF reports that beneficiaries may be denied a Medigap policy for a pre-existing condition if they switch from Medicare Advantage to traditional Medicare outside the initial 12-month trial period.⁠[3]
  • A few states give broader rights. Four states (Connecticut, Massachusetts, Maine, New York) require continuous or annual guaranteed-issue protections for people 65 and older, and four others (Delaware, Illinois, Minnesota, Rhode Island) have expanded protections. Michigan is not on either list.⁠[3]

Michigan note: DIFS states that applying after your 6-month open enrollment period subjects you to medical underwriting, and that you may be denied or charged more because of your health.⁠[12] Michigan isn't among the states with continuous or annual guaranteed-issue protections.⁠[3] Confirm your rights with DIFS (877-999-6442) or the Michigan SHIP / MI Options (1-800-803-7174) before you leave Original Medicare or drop a Medigap policy.⁠[8]⁠[9]

How to protect yourself

  • If you're unsure, consider starting with Original Medicare + Medigap during your open enrollment window. Moving to Medicare Advantage later doesn't require health screening: you can join with pre-existing conditions during Open Enrollment.⁠[10]
  • If you try Medicare Advantage at 65, set a reminder before your 12-month trial right ends.⁠[4]
  • Never cancel a Medigap policy until your new coverage is confirmed. Use the 30-day free look when switching Medigap policies.⁠[11]

Educational information only. This page is not legal, tax, financial, or insurance advice. Medicare rules and dollar amounts change every year. Before you act, confirm your situation with Medicare.gov or 1-800-MEDICARE (1-800-633-4227), Social Security, or your State Health Insurance Assistance Program (SHIP). In Michigan, the SHIP offers free, unbiased counseling at 1-800-803-7174.

Sources

  1. CMS/NAIC, Choosing a Medigap Policy (CMS Product No. 02110, March 2026), pp. 10–11, https://www.medicare.gov/publications/02110-medigap-guide-health-insurance.pdf (accessed November 11, 2026).
  2. CMS/NAIC, Choosing a Medigap Policy, p. 11, https://www.medicare.gov/publications/02110-medigap-guide-health-insurance.pdf (accessed November 11, 2026).
  3. KFF, "Medigap Guaranteed Issue Requirements: An Overview of Federal and State Rules," published Oct. 13, 2026, https://www.kff.org/medicare/medigap-guaranteed-issue-requirements-an-overview-of-federal-and-state-rules/ (accessed November 11, 2026).
  4. CMS, Understanding Medicare Advantage Plans (CMS Product No. 12026, April 2026), p. 5, https://www.medicare.gov/publications/12026-understanding-medicare-advantage-plans.pdf (accessed November 11, 2026).
  5. CMS, Medicare & You 2027, p. 82, https://www.medicare.gov/publications/10050-medicare-and-you.pdf (accessed November 11, 2026).
  6. CMS, Medicare & You 2027, p. 75, https://www.medicare.gov/publications/10050-medicare-and-you.pdf (accessed November 11, 2026).
  7. CMS, Medicare & You 2027, p. 32, https://www.medicare.gov/publications/10050-medicare-and-you.pdf (accessed November 11, 2026).
  8. Michigan DIFS, press release, Oct. 12, 2026, https://www.michigan.gov/difs/news-and-outreach/press-releases/2026/10/12/difs-and-mdhhs-share-tips-to-help-older-adults-avoid-scams-during-medicare-open-enrollment-period (accessed November 11, 2026).
  9. CMS, Medicare & You 2027, p. 115, https://www.medicare.gov/publications/10050-medicare-and-you.pdf (accessed November 11, 2026).
  10. CMS, Medicare & You 2027, p. 67, https://www.medicare.gov/publications/10050-medicare-and-you.pdf (accessed November 11, 2026).
  11. CMS/NAIC, Choosing a Medigap Policy, p. 26, https://www.medicare.gov/publications/02110-medigap-guide-health-insurance.pdf (accessed November 11, 2026).
  12. Michigan DIFS, "Medicare Supplement Policies," https://www.michigan.gov/difs/consumers/insurance/health-insurance/seniors/medicare-supp (accessed November 11, 2026).

Ready to compare plans?

Start your free quote online — no cost, no obligation.

Start Your Free Quotearrow_forward